Should you rent or buy a house in Canada ?
For some, home ownership is a ball and chain; for others, it is fulfilment of a dream
Many factors should be considered before buying. Generally if you buy a house and own it for at least 5 years it is better to own, than rent. However a real estate bubble
burst can cause serious losses if you have to sell your house.
Until your mortgage is paid in full actually
owning your house is an illusion. Even if you are mortgage free but you are 3 years in property tax arrears you will lose your house. Be forewarned about selling your house and paying back the mortgage early. On most fixed rate mortgages you will have to pay a 3 month interest penalty or an interest rate differential
penalty, whichever is the highest amount. That could be tens of thousands of dollars, if the interest rate jumps up. If these details were not disclosed to you when you took out a mortgage, contact
FCAC. Understand completely, the advantages and disadvantages of the mortgage type you choose. If you can't do a 20% down payment then you will have to get a 3rd party second mortgage, or pay additional mortgage default insurance through
CMHC. You can finance up to 95% of the house (but only if you "
qualify"). These rates could be up to
twice the first 80% mortgage interest rate. Only go this route if you plan on owning your home for many years and you plan on paying down the mortgage as fast as possible. If the housing market goes down as it did in the US, (although it would probably never be as
bad) be prepared for an increased
amortization period plus refinancing fees or putting down a lot more cash to maintain the 80% mortgage value of your home. Almost half of home-buyers are
required to buy mortgage default insurance. Remember those smiling faces at the bank when you first got your mortgage ? Miss 3 payments and your credit rating is destroyed and chances are you can't afford a lawyer to keep them at bay while you try to sell your house before they
repossess it. Buying a house is a gamble as prices
follow the stock market. However in 2011 only 1 in 252
Canadian mortgages are in
default, versus 1 in 45 in the
USA.
Are you ready for the 25 year commitment of mortgage, mortgage insurance and or life insurance, mortgage debt insurance, home insurance, property taxes, utility bills and maintenance repair bills ?
The Bottom Line: If your family income is $100,000 or more with
at least 20% banked for the down payment and you plan on living in the home for at least 5 years, go ahead and buy. If you do not meet this criteria you should rent, unless you don't mind paying much higher monthy payments, and being at high financial
risk, on a tight budget.
Caveats: Canadians have been living in a bubble for decades and there is a looming global
recession which
will affect Canada. Hopefully Canada will
weather it unlike most other countries. For 99% of the population mortgages are the largest single debt;
shop around. Banks will also try to sell you mortgage insurance, home insurance and pay your taxes in one easy monthly payment. Don't go for it - It's a scam. Pay your home insurance and taxes directly and get life insurance instead of mortgage insurance, saving a substantial amount of money with far more
benefits and flexibilty
. Mortgage default
insurance can increase the total mortgage repayment dramatically. Seek 3rd party
advice for the best mortgage stradegy.
Example of Purchase Versus Renting 1 year and 5 year with 5% Per Year Growth:
Actual Purchase cost: on a $350,000 house
$70,000 down payment + $280,000 fixed rate mortgage at 4% 5 year term 25 year amortization
(Mortgage payments $17,674.32 a year @ $1,472.86 a month)
land transfer tax $3,725 in
Ontario
Lawyer buying fees $1000
Total cost $354,725 upon purchase
Other
expenses such as a home inspection is not included
NOTE if it is a new house there is additional HST at 13% - Total cost $400,225 upon purchase
( Its maket value is still $350,000 @ 5% growth rate/year it's 4 years to break even on a sale )
Add $45,500 to the examples below to cost of ownership on a new house due to HST
Rental cost: on similar house
Expenses: Not including utilities
First year $19,000 a year @ $1600 a month
Insurance $300 (home owner pays the building insurance)
Following years 3.1% increase per year
Selling your house after 1 year for $367,500 @ 5% market growth
Mortgage payment $17,674
Outstanding mortgage $273,312 + $2,746 = $276,059
5% real estate fee $18,375 +
HST = $20,763
Lawyer buying fees $1,000
Lawyer selling fees $700
land transfer tax $3,725 in
Ontario
Insurance $600
Property Taxes in
Ottawa $4,422
Cost of 1 year ownership $27,442 versus Renting $19,300
============================================================
Cost of 1 year ownership $60,227 versus Renting $19,300
Total mortgage interest paid is the equivalent of paying 13% simple interest
Lesson learned in this case: Go with an Open Mortgage and save $35,531 (IRD)
============================================================
Selling your house after 5 years for $446,698 @ 5% market growth per year
Mortgage payment $88,371
Outstanding mortgage $243,750
5% real estate fee $22,335 +
HST = $25,238
Lawyer buying fees $1,000
Lawyer selling fees $700
land transfer tax $3,725 in
Ontario
Insurance $3,314 (5 years @ 5% per year increase)
Property Taxes in
Ottawa $23,477 (5 years @ 3% per year increase)
Cost of 5 year ownership $12,877 versus Renting $102,574
However if the market was bad and the house for sold for $350,000 (a real possibilty)
Cost of 5 year ownership $105,100 versus Renting $102,574